Neither Invasive nor Unprotected: The Legal Status of Muscovy Ducks in the United States
Journal Publication ResearchOnline@JCUMuscovy Ducks (Cairina moschata) live alongside people in communities around the world, as they have for centuries. Across most of the United States, they are considered non-native and often called “unprotected” or “invasive.” These labels can influence how people perceive and treat the ducks. This study examines whether those labels accurately describe the legal and wildlife status of Muscovy Ducks. Through a nationwide analysis, this research investigates animal-cruelty laws and invasive-species classifications at both federal and state levels. Results reveal a disconnect between common labels and legal reality. Every state has criminal laws that protect Muscovy Ducks from intentional cruelty, subject to exemptions. No federal agency formally classifies Muscovy Ducks as invasive. Among the 50 states, two list Muscovy Ducks as invasive, but each listing lacks science-based substantiation of harm in the state. “Non-native” itself does not fulfill the harm-based criteria of invasive status. These findings correct common descriptions of the legal protection and invasive status of Muscovy Ducks. Being non-native does not mean invasive, and being unprotected for conservation purposes does not mean unprotected from cruelty. When these terms are used loosely, they can make harmful treatment seem acceptable or justified. Rectifying this rhetoric is important to help prevent misunderstanding and mistreatment.
Animals
Animals
16
2076-2615
N/A
21
14
N/A
MDPI
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
10.3390/ani16213472
