Scrutinizing the impact of policy instruments on adoption of agricultural conservation practices using Bayesian expert models

Dean, Angela J.;Eberhard, Rachel;Baresi, Umberto;Coggan, Anthea;Deane, Felicity;Hamman, Evan;Helmstedt, Kate J.;Loechel, Barton;Jarvis, Diane;Mayfield, Helen;Stevens, Lillian;Taylor, Bruce;Vella, Karen

Diane Jarvis

Abstract

Policy instruments—such as regulation, financial incentives, and agricultural extension—are commonly applied by governments to promote sustainable agricultural practices and tackle ecosystem degradation. Despite substantial investment, little data are available to gauge the impact of evolving policy mixes. We constructed a Bayesian network model to explore relationships between pol-icy instruments, contextual factors, and adoption. Applying a series of scenarios, we present examples of how different instruments influence adoption and how their effectiveness is shaped by contextual factors. Scenarios highlight that the effect of policy instruments is often modest, and constrained by diverse practice and population characteristics. These findings allow us to reflect on the role of policy instruments, and the conditions necessary to support practice change. For example, our findings raise questions about the role of financial benefits versus financial capacity, and highlight the potential importance of concepts such as mental bandwidth in shaping both motivation and capacity to adopt.

Journal

Conservation Letters

Publication Name

N/A

Volume

ISBN/ISSN

1755-263X

Edition

N/A

Issue

Pages Count

Location

N/A

Publisher

Wiley-Blackwell

Publisher Url

N/A

Publisher Location

N/A

Publish Date

N/A

Url

N/A

Date

N/A

EISSN

N/A

DOI

10.1111/conl.12988