Statement in Support of: “Virology under the Microscope—a Call for Rational Discourse”

Journal Contribution ResearchOnline@JCU
Speck, Peter;Mackenzie, Jason;Bull, Rowena A.;Slobedman, Barry;Drummer, Heidi;Fraser, Johanna;Herrero, Lara;Helbig, Karla;Londrigan, Sarah;Moseley, Gregory;Prow, Natalie;Hansman, Grant;Edwards, Robert;Ahlenstiel, Chantelle;Abendroth, Allison;Tscharke, David;Hobson-Peters, Jody;Kriiger-Loterio, Robson;Parry, Rhys;Marsh, Glenn;Harding, Emma;Jacques, David A.;Gartner, Matthew J.;Lee, Wen Shi;McAuley, Julie;Vaz, Paola;Sainsbury, Frank;Tate, Michelle D.;Sinclair, Jane;Imrie, Allison;Rawlinson, Stephen;Harman, Andrew;Carr, Jillian M.;Monson, Ebony A.;Hibma, Merilyn;Mahony, Timothy J.;Tu, Thomas;Center, Robert J.;Shrestha, Lok Bahadur;Hall, Robyn;Warner, Morgyn;Ward, Vernon;Anderson, Danielle E.;Eyre, Nicholas S.;Netzler, Natalie E.;Peel, Alison J.;Revill, Peter;Beard, Michael;Legione, Alistair R.;Spencer, Alexandra J.;Idris, Adi;Forwood, Jade;Sarker, Subir;Purcell, Damian F.J.;Bartlett, Nathan;Deerain, Joshua M.;Brew, Bruce J.;Asgari, Sassan;Farrell, Helen;Khromykh, Alexander;Enosi Tuipulotu, Daniel;Anderson, David;Mese, Sevim;Tayyar, Yaman;Edenborough, Kathryn;Uddin, Jasim Muhammad;Hussain, Abrar;Daymond, Connor J.I.;Agius, Jacinta;Johnson, Karyn N.;Shirmast, Paniz;Abedinzadeshahri, Mahdi;MacDiarmid, Robin;Ashley, Caroline L.;Laws, Jay;Furfaro, Lucy L.;Burton, Thomas D.;Johnson, Stephen M.R.;Telikani, Zahra;Petrone, Mary;Roby, Justin A.;Samer, Carolyn;Suhrbier, Andreas;Van Der Kamp, April;Cunningham, Anthony;Donato, Celeste;Mahar, Jackie;Black, Wesley D.;Vasudevan, Subhash;Lenchine, Roman;Spann, Kirsten;Rawle, Daniel J.;Rudd, Penny;Neil, Jessica;Kingston, Richard;Newsome, Timothy P.;Kim, Ki Wook;Mak, Johnson;Lowry, Kym;Bryant, Nathan;Meers, Joanne;Roberts, Jason A.;McMillan, Nigel;Labzin, Larisa I.;Slonchak, Andrii;Hugo, Leon E.;Henzeler, Bennett;Newton, Natalee D.;David, Cassandra T.;Reading, Patrick C.;Esneau, Camille;Briody, Tatiana;Nasr, Najla;McNeale, Donna;McSharry, Brian;Fakhri, Omid;Horsburgh, Bethany A.;Logan, Grant;Howley, Paul;Young, Paul
Subir Sarker
Abstract

[Extract] We, members of the Australasian Virology Society, agree with and support the statement entitled “Virology under the Microscope—a Call for Rational Discourse” (1). Like virologists everywhere, we have worked with scientist and clinician colleagues worldwide to develop knowledge, tests, and interventions which collectively have reduced the number of deaths due to COVID-19 and curtailed its economic impact. Such work adds to the extraordinary achievements resulting from virology research that have delivered vaccines and/or antivirals against a long list of diseases and global scourges, including AIDS, smallpox, and polio (1). We believe the question of the origin of SARS-CoV-2 should be approached with an open mind and in consideration of the best scientific evidence available. We concur with the view that the zoonosis hypothesis has the strongest supporting evidence (2–4), and this is a scenario that has been observed repeatedly in the past (5), including in Australia (6). Recent data strongly support the zoonosis hypothesis (7). We share the concern that emotive and fear-based dialogues in this area add to public confusion and can lead to ill-informed condemnation of virology research.

Journal

mBio

Publication Name

N/A

Volume

14

ISBN/ISSN

2150-7511

Edition

N/A

Issue

3

Pages Count

3

Location

N/A

Publisher

American Society for Microbiology

Publisher Url

N/A

Publisher Location

N/A

Publish Date

N/A

Url

N/A

Date

N/A

EISSN

N/A

DOI

10.1128/mbio.00815-23